Another Toronto Is Possible
We deserve a budget based around
Supports, Not Police
Community protest at City Budget Committee
Hundreds of Torontonians gathered at City Hall this week to oppose Mayor John Tory’s $50 million police budget increase and to demand that the city instead reallocate 50% of the TPS budget to urgently needed community supports. The police budget is the largest single line item in Toronto city budget, double the combined funds allotted to the Public Library, Public Health, the Toronto Region Conservation Authority, the Toronto Community Housing Agencies, and the Association of Community Centers. Speakers demanded a city that prioritizes real safety for our communities, condemned the unacceptable levels of police surveillance, harassment, and violence, and articulated a need for police-free futures, and racial, gendered and economic justice for all Torontonians.
Other community members took the protest inside and disrupted the City Budget Committee meeting, demanding that councilors come out and face families who have lost loved ones to police violence, and holding up a banner saying “Defund and Abolish All Police.” They were forcibly removed from the room, and welcomed by the crowds outside.
Indigenous communities reject the expansion of colonial policing
Elder Wanda Whitebird, Mi'kmaq from Paktnkek-Niktuek First Nation and community knowledge keeper with No More Silence, opened the gathering with welcome, thanks, and prayers. “The reason why I wanted to come out is that it’s a debate for 50 million dollars,” she said, “And I don’t think the police department in Toronto needs another 50 million dollars.” Wanda led a smudge while Indigenous community members drummed and danced to open the gathering.
Brianna Olson-Pitawanakwat, Anishnawbek from Wikwemikong and co-founder of Toronto Indigenous Harm Reduction, spoke to the relationship between policing and ongoing colonial violence, and denounced the allocation of funds to the police, stating, “Police have played a huge role in the destabilization of our communities, historically and today. Every day in our communities, we are burying our loved ones. If you look to the reports –– The Royal Commission on Indigenous Peoples, the Truth and Reconciliation report, the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls report ––every single one names police as willing participants in the brutal colonization and genocide of our people. The over representation of Indigenous women in prisons is an international human rights crisis. The relationship is one that we cannot reconcile as Indigenous people… Please stand with us as we denounce this funding increase, and the Toronto police.”
Families speaking back: Mental health supports, not death
In the summer of 2020, after the death of Regis Korchinski-Paquet at the hands of police during their response to a mental health crisis, over 10,000 people took to the streets in Toronto in defense of Black lives, demanding the city defund police and invest in communities. Regis’s mother, Claudette Beals-Clayton, made clear that her daughters death was preventable and that Tory’s police budget increase showed he had no respect for the families of people in crisis. She told onlookers:
“My daughter had a problem, and I called for help. She died. They were in my apartment for exactly one minute with her, and she was over the balcony. They backed her over the balcony. Our children should be alive. These people were supposed to protect and serve us. She’s the child that we don’t get to talk to anymore. She’s gone. And these guys want to give the police $50 million?”
Since the 2020 protests, the city allocated some funding to alternative response methods for mental health crisis, but they did not meet the widespread call - supported by CAMH - to end the practice of police responding to mental health calls. With over $1 billion for policing standing among the largest lines of the city budget, necessary life saving services continue to be underfunded. The result has been more tragic and preventable deaths: beloved Jane Finch community member, 32-year old Taresh Bobby Ramroop died in a police encounter during a mental health crisis. In the words of his mother, Debbie:
“My son Bobby died during a mental health crisis, when he needed his family. He was loved by his aunties in Guyana. He loved Jane and Finch. He loved my cooking... I’m grieving. I lost my son so suddenly by the hands of Toronto police. The police came to the door. I told them I was alright. They insisted they needed to enter my home and they would get the super to open the door if I didn’t. The police were at my door for three hours or so. I got support from my community, mental health support: she is a neighbor. I didn’t need police, I needed a mental health worker. Why didn’t they let us help my son when he was in crisis: his family, the community, us? We raised Bobby his entire life and until that fateful day when the police came…The Toronto police are responsible for my son’s death.”
She and Kevenie, Bobby’s sister, highlighted that their community had real needs, but that instead the city continued to prioritize police funding. Kevenie added “Instead of funding the police we should be funding after school programs, boys and girls clubs. My brother Bob didn’t need the SWAT team, he needed mental health workers.” Debbie told the crowd: “The Toronto police budget is too big, and they are killing our community. And they are taking innocent lives. Instead of putting dollars into their budget, put into mental health services, our community, our neighbors, before and after school programs, hospital beds, help people find homes and not have to be living on the streets and shelters. Costs of living are going up and people are struggling. The city needs to do better and stop funding the police. So many people in the city tell you where the money needs to go. Listen to us. Listen to the people. Defund the police.”
Pushing back against Tory’s narrative on violence
Tory is cynically exploiting the real and important issue of TTC violence to drum up support for increased policing yet again. But police funding is not the same as working to end violence. The Roots of Youth Violence report commissioned by the Ontario government concluded that increased community support ––not more police funding ––are required to prevent violence.
Robyn Maynard, member of No Pride in Policing and a professor at the University of Toronto, highlighted that while the recent acts of violence are alarming, and preventing violence is a priority, we shouldn’t let John Tory or the police dominate the narrative to justify their ever-expanding demands for police funds, power, and resources. She pointed to data that demonstrates a general decrease in violence when compared to 20 years ago, and that just as importantly, police do not prevent violence but often exacerbate it.
Shelagh Pizey-Allen, from TTC Riders, a grassroots transit user advocacy group, addressed the recent concerns about violence experienced by transit users and workers. “I want to talk about safety, because safety is very important and we are seeing a rise in documented violence on the TTC,” she said, but “if we need a safer TTC, why is the mayor cutting service late at night? If we need a safer TTC, why is the mayor cutting service at all times of day across the system? This is a safety issue for people who use wheelchairs... If we need a safer TTC, where are the resources to combat racism and sexual violence on the TTC? … if we need a safer TTC, why are the frontline staff on the TTC being phased out? … and if we need a safer TTC, why are there zero resources going to mental health supports?” Instead of investing in more special constables – who just enforce fares and harass poor people – the city needs to ensure that our public transit system is well-staffed, well-funded, accessible, and reliable, offering greater mobility, supports, safety, and wellbeing for all Torontonians.
Policing doesn’t prevent violence: What does real community safety look like?
Organizations from across the city spoke to the ways that they are already meaningfully working to prevent and respond to harm in their communities. Representatives made it clear that police – far from keeping us safer – only increase violence, and spoke powerfully to evidence-based pathways towards actual safety and wellbeing for all Torontonians.
Suzanne Narain, a member of Jane Finch Action Against Poverty, condemned Tory’s status-quo vision for the city. “Let it be known that if this budget passes, it will mean MORE police violence to mainly Black, racialized and Indigenous folks. It will mean more homelessness, more pain and suffering for low income, hardworking, and beautiful communities like ours. There are too many deaths, injuries, and tragedies at the hands of the police. More police is never the answer.” She reminded us that communities already have the answers, and require more resources and support from the city. “More community investment, more hiring of community workers, social workers, and youth workers is crucial, more investments in housing, enhancement of our public education, public health, social employment services… We have to work and build a city together that works better for more of us.”
Speakers from Butterfly: Asian and Migrant Sex Workers Support Network emphasized how policing and criminalization increases workers’ experiences of harm, and compromises their own community-led efforts to meaningfully protect each other from violence. “Our community consistently confronts laws that criminalize our work and our status, leaving us more vulnerable to exploitation and abuse,” they said, “It is because the police do not keep us safe that we must creatively support one another and continue to advocate… We demand rights, not rescue.”
Sean Ihn from SMASH, a student collective at the University of Toronto, raised the alarm about police violence on campus: “Our own students are being brutalized by the police, harassed by the police, handcuffed by the police, all for what? For having a mental health crisis.” The city must put “people over profit,” Ihn said and prioritize housing, education, healthcare, supports, and “giving the people what we need.”
Housing, Not Harassment
Toronto is in a housing crisis. Rents are up 20%, the cost of living is climbing, and people in the city are increasingly unable to cover their basic costs. More and more of our neighbours are living on the streets, facing an under-resourced shelter system that turns away over a hundred people a day, and inadequate basic services. Instead of prioritizing investment in much-needed affordable housing and other long term solutions, the city is spending millions of dollars to violently evict people from parks and tents.
Jordn Geldart, a representative from ESN Parkdale, spoke to the crowd about his experience being targeted and harassed as an unhoused Indigenous man. In his words, “Last summer, I got taken on a Starlight Tour, well-known on the West coast for making “problematic Indigenous men” go missing. They brought me to the Trenton Military prison. I have no need to be at a military prison just for being homeless.” Speaking to Tory’s new “strong mayor” powers, he added, “These extra powers should be going toward helping people not criminalizing them and arresting them for being homeless.”
Fighting for Abolitionist Futures
A statement from Desmond Cole and Beverley Bain, written on behalf of the No Pride in Policing Coalition, was read to the crowd: “We protest for Indigenous peoples, for their sovereignty, land back, and the fulfillment of treaties long denied. We protest for Black people harmed by the state for generations. We protest for those without a safe place to use drugs, or a safe supply. We protest for queer and trans people who don’t report violence because they fear the police. We protest for people who don’t know where they will sleep tonight. We protest for every person who needed mental health supports and got the cops instead. We won’t stop! We will keep up the fight for sustainable livable communities. We will keep doing this till we are Free!”
Momentum is building: Join us!
Ever since Tory announced his intention to give even more money to TPS, residents have been expressing their outrage, online and in-person, about these troubling priorities. Across the two days of public hearings at the City’s Budget Committee last week, the major theme that emerged was widespread anger over the proposed increase to the police budget, and the urgent need to reallocate funds away from policing and towards the services and supports that communities actually need. At the Police Services Board meeting the week prior, over 50 Torontonians submitted deputations opposing the budget increase (only four - representing BIAs concerned about property damage - were in favour). Tory claims that Torontonians want this increase in policing – we must continue to make it clear that his status quo agenda is widely rejected, and that communities know that #AnotherTorontoIsPossible.
If you want to take further action around the city budget and help build an abolitionist future in which our communities all have the resources and supports to thrive, you can check out the rest of our Month of Action and sign up for updates at AnotherToronto.ca.
The action was jointly organized by the No Pride in Policing Coalition, SURJ Toronto, No More Silence, Toronto Indigenous Harm Reduction, Jane-Finch Action Against Poverty, Doctors for Defunding Police, Policing-Free Schools, Bloordale Community Response, and No One Is Illegal Toronto.
Photos of the speakers are from Daniel Tseghay.
An edited version of this statement was published on The Breach.
